Re: [hm-staff] Changes on the MNT-BY ?
Thank you for your email. I woudl like to confirm that there is no change in procedure or policy
in area that you outlined in this email. Could you kindly send your examples and queries to
hostmaster or helpdesk emails so we can investigate and help you accordingly. You probably know
that all NIRs member's objects should be maintained by NIRs not by APNIC.
On Mon, 13 Oct 2003, Ahmad Alkazimy wrote:
> Dear all,
> I've just been realize after we query some objects (especially the Reverse
> Delegation's and the ASN Autnum Objects), it seems to be the MNT-BY has
> been changed from the previous.
> Previously, those objects are protected by the NIR Maintainers. Now has
> been changed and protected by the ISP's maintainers.
> Is their any policies changes on the APNIC Policies regarding on this one ?
> Seems to be getting more difficult for us to maintain these objects in the
> future, especially when we want to know which objects are belongs to each
> of our members.
> For example:
> Usually, we are using one command to query all the inetnum objects, reverse
> delegation, aut-num, person, and role objects:
> whois3 -h whois.apnic.net -i mb mnt-apjii-id |more
> All objects are protected by the NIR Maintainer Objects will be shown,
> include the Inetnum, Reverse, Aut-num and followed by the Role and Person
> Objects of each members.
> Now we have to use, different Maintainer Objects to query those objects.
> Difficult for NIR's to maintained these objects when they have a large
> number of members.
> This changes will also made more difficulties, when in the future the
> numbers of growth of the NIR's members become more huge and became more
> complex to do some queries.
> We look forward to hearing from you all,
> Ahmad Khalil Alkazimy, Internet Resources Analyst <ahmad at apjii dot or dot id>
> Asosiasi Penyelenggara Jasa Internet Indonesia [APJII]
> Indonesian ISP Association
> hostmaster at apjii dot or dot id
> Telp +62-21-5296.0634 Fax +62-21-5296.0635
> sig-nir mailing list
> sig-nir at lists dot apnic dot net
> Hostmaster-staff mailing list
> Hostmaster-staff at apnic dot net